Living In Long Island's Five Towns: What To Know About Neighborhoods, Schools, And Commutes

The Five Towns is an informal grouping of villages and hamlets in Nassau County, New York, on the South Shore of western Long Island, adjoining the border with the borough of Queens in New York City. The Five Towns is normally considered to be made up of Lawrence, Cedarhurst, Woodmere, Inwood, and Hewlett (Hewlett Bay Park, Hewlett Neck, Hewlett Harbor). This close-knit cluster of communities has earned a reputation as one of Long Island's most desirable residential areas, balancing suburban comfort with convenient urban access.

Five Towns is one of Long Island's most desirable areas, offering a perfect balance of suburban charm, scenic beauty, and easy access to the city, with tree-lined streets, beautiful parks, and proximity to the South Shore's beaches making it ideal for anyone seeking a peaceful lifestyle without losing touch with urban conveniences. Whether you're considering a move to this affluent region or simply curious about what life is like here, understanding the distinct characteristics of each community, the quality of schools, and commuting options is essential to making an informed decision.

Understanding the Five Towns: Location and History

The Five Towns is a vibrant tapestry woven from five distinct hamlets within the sprawling Town of Hempstead: Lawrence, Cedarhurst, Woodmere, Hewlett, and Inwood. The informal grouping of Cedarhurst, Hewlett, Inwood, Lawrence and Woodmere has been called the Five Towns since 1931, when Community Chest groups, organized for charitable giving, banded together to form the Five Towns Community Chest.

Despite the reputation of the South Shore of Nassau County being more urbanized than the North Shore, the Five Towns retains hamlets that resemble areas along Long Island's Gold Coast on the North Shore with enormous mansions and exclusive private communities along the water. Inwood, however, is much less affluent than the other "towns," with a more urban character and a significantly more ethnically diverse population. This diversity of character across the five communities means potential residents can find neighborhoods suited to various lifestyles and budgets.

Distinctive Neighborhoods and Community Character

Lawrence: Elegance and Prestige

As you enter Lawrence, you're immediately struck by an undeniable air of quiet affluence, characterized by grand, stately homes often set on expansive, meticulously maintained properties, where privacy and tradition are highly valued, offering residents a serene and sophisticated lifestyle. The presence of exclusive private country clubs further underscores its refined atmosphere, making it a desirable locale for those seeking a tranquil yet luxurious suburban experience.

Cedarhurst: The Vibrant Commercial Heart

Cedarhurst is a bustling commercial hub with a thriving downtown, offering a wide array of shops, boutiques, and eateries. The neighborhood serves as the cultural and economic center of the Five Towns, with Central Avenue functioning as the primary commercial corridor. The blend of retail, dining, and community services makes Cedarhurst the most walkable of the five communities.

Woodmere: Family-Friendly Balance

Woodmere features a mix of residential styles and a welcoming, family-oriented atmosphere. Woodmere offers larger residential lots, established trees, and privacy-focused landscapes. This makes it particularly appealing to families seeking space and established neighborhood infrastructure.

Hewlett: Waterfront Appeal

Hewlett combines suburban charm with waterfront properties and diverse housing options. The community offers a more spread-out, suburban feel with access to water-related recreation and tree-lined streets that contribute to its residential appeal.

Inwood: Gateway Diversity

Inwood is the most diverse of the five, providing a gateway to the region and a mix of residential and commercial areas. As the entry point from Far Rockaway, Inwood offers relatively more affordable options within the Five Towns while maintaining the area's basic amenities and services.

Public and Private School Options

The Five Towns benefits from strong educational infrastructure serving families at all levels. There are two school districts in the Five Towns, the Lawrence Public Schools (District 15) and the Hewlett-Woodmere School District (District 14). Roughly speaking, the Lawrence school district contains all of Lawrence, Cedarhurst and Inwood, and parts of Woodmere, North Woodmere, and Woodsburgh, while the Hewlett-Woodmere district contains all of Hewlett and part of Woodmere and extends partly into the neighboring villages of Lynbrook and Valley Stream.

Hewlett's school ranking and train commute make it a Long Island town with a short commute to NYC with good schools. Hewlett is the most affordable Long Island town with good schools and a short commute to NYC. Both public school districts maintain strong academic reputations and offer comprehensive educational programs.

School DistrictCoverage AreasType
Lawrence Public Schools (District 15)Lawrence, Cedarhurst, Inwood, parts of WoodmerePublic K-12
Hewlett-Woodmere School District (District 14)Hewlett, part of Woodmere, parts of Lynbrook and Valley StreamPublic K-12
HAFTR (Hebrew Academy of the Five Towns and Rockaway)All Five Towns communitiesPrivate PreK-12
DRS Yeshiva High School for BoysAll Five Towns communitiesPrivate grades 9-12

Private School Ecosystem

In addition to public schools, there are many private schools in the Five Towns. HAFTR (co-ed, PreK–12), DRS yeshiva high school for boys, SKA for girls, and Shulamith anchor one of the most complete day-school ecosystems outside Brooklyn. This robust private school infrastructure reflects the region's strong commitment to education and offers families diverse educational philosophies and approaches.

Commuting to New York City and Beyond

One of the Five Towns' greatest assets is its accessibility to Manhattan for work and recreation. These communities all have a stop on the Far Rockaway Branch of the Long Island Rail Road. Direct LIRR access to Penn Station makes the Five Towns a realistic commute for Manhattan workers. This reliable rail connection has made the Five Towns a preferred choice for professionals who want suburban living without sacrificing career opportunities in the city.

Key Transportation Takeaways 📍

  • 🚂 Long Island Rail Road access connects directly to Penn Station in Manhattan
  • Multiple stations serve the five communities, providing convenient pickup points throughout the region
  • Schedule flexibility with various departure times during peak and off-peak hours
  • Far Rockaway Branch serves all Five Towns hamlets as designated stops
  • Car-dependent for local errands, but public transit viable for commuters
  • Proximity to major highways provides alternative transportation options

Community Character and Lifestyle

The Five Towns has always stood out as an affluent and well-respected region in southwestern Nassau County. The area fosters a strong sense of community with active neighborhood organizations, local events, and family-oriented amenities. Residents enjoy boutique shopping, local cafes, and exceptional schools that contribute to its family-friendly reputation.

Beyond residential appeal, the Five Towns hosts various cultural events and local traditions that strengthen neighborhood bonds. The relatively contained geography of the five communities means residents often interact across town lines, creating a unified regional identity despite distinct characteristics of each hamlet.

Proximity to Recreation and Natural Features

The Five Towns' location on the South Shore places residents near valuable recreational opportunities. Inwood is minutes from the beaches of Atlantic Beach and the Rockaways. The area's tree-lined streets, beautiful parks, and proximity to the South Shore's beaches make it ideal for anyone seeking a peaceful lifestyle. Parks, golf clubs, and beach access provide year-round recreation options for families and individuals.

What To Consider Before Moving

Real Estate Market Considerations 💡

  • Property values vary significantly across the five communities, with Lawrence and Cedarhurst typically commanding premium prices
  • Housing styles range from single-family homes on spacious lots to condominium and multi-family options, particularly in commercial areas
  • School district assignment affects property values and should be confirmed during the buying process
  • Waterfront and estate properties command higher values in Hewlett and surrounding areas
  • Permit and zoning regulations vary by community and may affect renovation or expansion plans
  • Taxes and local fees differ between villages and should be factored into overall affordability

Potential residents should carefully assess which of the five communities best aligns with their lifestyle preferences. Lawrence appeals to those seeking established elegance and privacy, while Cedarhurst attracts those who prefer walkable commercial areas and cultural activity. Woodmere and Hewlett serve families prioritizing schools and suburban space, while Inwood offers diversity and relatively greater affordability. All benefit from the region's excellent transportation, schools, and community infrastructure.

Practical Information for Residents

The Five Towns' informal structure means that services, utilities, and amenities may vary slightly between communities. Prospective buyers should confirm that specific neighborhoods offer desired services such as trash collection, water and sewer systems, and emergency services. Local government is managed at the village or hamlet level, so zoning, permits, and regulations differ across the five communities.

The region is well-served by shopping, dining, and entertainment options, with Cedarhurst's downtown serving as the primary commercial hub. Most residents maintain automobiles for daily needs, though the LIRR provides reliable transit for commuters. The Five Towns' proximity to other Long Island communities also allows easy access to additional services and entertainment venues.

Living in the Five Towns offers a distinctive suburban experience that balances community connection with proximity to urban opportunities. Each neighborhood brings its own flavor and appeal, allowing prospective residents to choose based on personal priorities—whether that's elegance and tradition, walkable commercial districts, family-friendly atmosphere, waterfront living, or affordable diversity. The strong school systems, reliable commute infrastructure, and established sense of place make this region an attractive choice for Long Island homebuyers seeking quality of life without sacrificing convenience.